With the chaos of Thanksgiving behind us, it’s time to turn up the heat on the Hot Stove season. But here’s where it gets controversial: while many are eyeing big names, I’m arguing for a more strategic, budget-conscious approach that could still make waves in 2026. Let’s dive in—because the A’s have some critical decisions to make as December rolls around.
Brendan Donovan: Why the Hype Might Not Be Worth It
Brendan Donovan checks a lot of boxes: left-handed hitter, strong on-base skills, and a solid defender at second base. But here’s the part most people miss—the market for Donovan is overheating. Reports suggest he’s drawing significant interest, which likely means a bidding war. And while he’s a reliable everyday player, he’s not worth compromising the farm system for someone like Gage Jump. The A’s can find comparable talent without breaking the bank or sacrificing their future.
Sung-Mun Song vs. Jake Cronenworth: A Trade Worth Exploring
Sung-Mun Song could be a solid addition, but Korean sources hint he might land in San Diego instead. This opens an intriguing door: trading for Jake Cronenworth. At first glance, Cronenworth’s career .406 SLG doesn’t scream “first baseman,” but his versatility at 1B/2B, affordable contract through 2030 ($11.43M/year), and excellent plate discipline make him a compelling option. Plus, with Luis Arraez hitting free agency, there’s room on the infield for both Cronenworth and a rising star like Leo DeVries.
The Padres’ Perspective
San Diego’s farm system could use a boost after trading much of it to the A’s for Mason Miller. Offering prospects like Colby Thomas, Tommy White, or even pitching talents like Mason Barnett or JT Ginn could sweeten the deal. Cronenworth’s age (32 in January) might raise eyebrows, but his skills age well, and his 2025 fielding struggles could be chalked up to injury or variance rather than decline.
Free Agent Pitchers: The Holy Grails
Signing free agent starters is tricky for the A’s, given their ballpark’s hitter-friendly reputation and the tendency for SPs to be overpaid. Framber Valdez and Ranger Suarez are out of reach, but two names stand out as exceptions: Chris Bassitt and Tyler Rogers.
Bassitt, a familiar face from his six seasons in Oakland, could slot in as a reliable #3 starter. MLBTR predicts a 2-year, $38M deal, but the A’s could outbid by offering a third year. At 37 in 2026, his bullpen potential adds value if he transitions from starter. And this is the part most people miss—his ability to pound the zone (sub-3.00 BB rate in six of his last seven seasons) makes him a low-risk, high-reward option.
Tyler Rogers, turning 35 next month, is another gem. His submarine delivery is arm-friendly, and his pinpoint command means he’ll age gracefully. MLBTR projects a 2-year, $18M deal, but I’d push for 3 years at $27M. His injury risk is minimal, and his style is a perfect fit for the A’s long-term strategy.
The Bold Vision for 2026
Land Cronenworth, Bassitt, and Rogers for a $30M payroll bump and a mid-range prospect, and the A’s could compete with the Seattle Mariners or anyone else in 2026. With Gage Jump and Leo DeVries knocking on the door at AAA, this roster would be balanced, affordable, and ready to win.
But Here’s the Question
Is this the right move, or should the A’s aim higher? Are Bassitt and Rogers worth the stretch, or should they focus on younger talent? Let’s debate it—because the stove is hot, and the time to act is now. What’s your take?
